Ian Evatt is the latest to fall from the deck of HMS Blackpool FC - not so much a destroyer designed to piss the league as a rubber boat inflated with lots of expensive air but with a slow puncture and no oars so it just goes around in ponderous circles getting lower in the water as we go.
Chucking Evo overboard lightens the load a bit - but let's be honest, a) he's not as big as he once was and b) this boat doesn't need a skipper, it needs towing into port, scrapping and something better launched in its place.
I feel like I've written the same article about 50 times. I'm not going to repeat all the same stuff - but in summary, we're not very imaginative in how we recruit players and staff, we don't appear to work to a plan, the underlying performance metrics (oooh, get me!) have been dreadful and got steadily worse since Critch 2.0 drove away in the Volvo for a comforting Shepherds pie and a soothing weekend away in the caravan with Janine.
Ian Evatt going is the right call. I don't know if it was his idea, a mutual agreement or he was pushed but his time was up. I never really got into caricaturing Evo as I did with other managers because there always seemed to be something vulnerable about him. Whereas I would imagine Mick wandering round Homebase humming the intro to 80 soft rock songs, Bruce happily testing sofas in DFS or Critch alphabetising the contents of his kitchen cupboards, Evo seemed to occupy a kind of hinterland, a non place, a kind of purgatory. He seemed a strange blend of supreme confidence and fragility and to imagine him beyond football seemed, well, cruel.
That's human though and humans are contradictory. The modern world with its character limits and meme length attention spans wants everyone to be either "a hero" or "a villain" - people can be and are both. I'm good sometimes and I'm a cunt sometimes. So are you.
Evatt is an intelligent and erudite man. There's huge potential in him. His early interviews and some of his decisions were thoughtful, detailed and he showed passion and reflection. As time went on, he seemed to dull, to diminish, to retreat into a world of stubbon tactics babble that made Critch seem plain speaking. "Pass detail" not being absorbed. "Hot mode" staying active too long and of course, "take the goals out of the game..."
Critchley never had the the same twinkle in his eye second time round either. Evatt came back to management in glitter of new teeth, new hair, new waistline, born again God fearing energy. I was sceptical about appointing him, but his evident desire and seriousness won me round. Vibes might work. For whatever reason, Evatt seemed to struggle after a point. Whether football or his own life, I don't know - but it became increasingly painful watching him look like he was carrying the weight of the world, whilst telling us all that actually, despite the evidence, everything is fine.
Everything wasn't fine. Nothing suggested it was fine. Nothing pointed to us turning corners or being spectacularly unlucky - but Evatt grimly insisted the thinnest of evidence pointed to the certainty of success.
People tell themselves what they want to believe. Evatt talked of manifesting and of belief and faith. That's easy to mock, and there was something of the Jake Humphrey interview about it all - but there's also truth. No one does anything remarkable without believing they can do it. Things that change the world are often born from a stubborn refusal to give up an idea. The problem was, it became apparent that if Evo's words said he did believe, his body language, his tone of voice and crucially, what was manifesting in reality on the pitch suggested otherwise.
Ian Evatt was a lynchpin of our best team in my lifetime. That is who he is. He came, he had a go, it didn't work. It ended in a way that was really, the polar opposite of a fairytale. Being sacked on your birthday from the club you do obviously hold dear is more of a nightmare than a dream.
I hope he's ok and I hope Ian Evatt, the defensive colossus and central character in that great dream of a side is still remembered thus. There's no shame in failing and it's better to have lived your dreams than spent your life on nothing.
So what now?
The focus will be on the manager, of course it will. There'll be a betting market, random names, romantic choices, rumours and all of that stuff. Everyone will have their view, including me. For what it's worth, we have to go and get a first time manager, someone desperate for their break. I'm tired of the boring, safe appointments that get us nowhere.
Here's the thing though. If the job is to somehow paddle a leaking dinghy to shore, does it really matter?
We know we've got a squad that has been expensively assembled but that lacks some of the key parts that would make it functional. We know that squad is ageing and some of them already are past their realistic peak impact points - if they were going to work, they'd have done so by now. You can't build a team round injury prone 30-somethings. We know that multiple different approaches, multiple different personalities have tried and failed in the last half decade. There is a significant timespan in which to suggest that there is something not right (I.e we keep spending money, but it doesn't get us anywhere, even though we keep changing manager) and that thing has to be above the manager because surely, if it was easily fixable, one of the managers would have fixed it.
What I want to know now - before we get anyone in, before we pin our hopes on the next fall guy in waiting, is:
What is our plan? How is that plan to be executed? How do the different areas of the club relate to that plan? How are they managed to ensure they are working in sync with the overall idea?
The 'plan' can't be "appoint a new manager and then just follow him" - that's not how it works in modern football. The plan has to be in place in order to appoint a manager because that manager has to fit into what already exists to some extent.
Modern clubs consist of multiple departments. We can moan about that and yearn for the days when it was 3 or 4 blokes, one who had a sponge, one who went and watched matches to find players, one who did the training and one who picked the team and had the final say... That's all very appealing to the nostalgic in us all - but that's not how it is anymore.
Clubs, even at our level have many employees and the manager needs to fit into the work done by them. Yes, you can tinker with the first team staff a bit - but it's just not feasible to repeatedly rip out the entire structure and put a new one in every time the club changes direction - and change direction is what we've done every season since the infamous Steven Gerrard phonecall to Critch.
We need to stop. We need to decide what we're doing and then we need to do it. We need to ask difficult questions.
Why is our recruitment so poor?
Why have we got a perennial injury crisis?
Why has no manager succeeded despite having competitive budgets?
We have to wonder about the decision making that has led to this. We have to wonder about the processes that have informed those choices. We have to wonder about the leadership that has held (or not held) the different elements of the club to account and ultimately, must take responsibility for the ongoing slow drift backwards.
Successful projects of all kinds have an approach. They have a consistency. That consistency allows people to be appraised against clear and evident standards. It allows people to understand what their job is and to become good at their jobs because the job doesn't keep changing arbitrarily.
Where a clear focus exists, people actually become more creative - because their minds are trained on "how do we get there?" and their imagination harnessed to a purpose.
I feel like I could re-watch every interview with David Downes in the last three years and boil it down to "good players" and "get promotion"
That's fine to a point. That's clearly the goal - but it's not enough to build a project around. It's not enough to tell people what they're doing and how they should approach it. It's an end goal, not a strategy. If the strategy isn't evident to people like me (and probably you) who are pathetically obsessed with a football club that we probably should have grown out of at 15 - then is it evident within the club?
Simply saying "good players" and "challenge for promotion" is like presenting a business plan to "sell things" and "make money" - that's the goal, of course it is, but any company needs more than that to guide it. If you turned up at work and all you knew was 'make a profit' and nothing else, then how would you know what to do? Football clubs are increasingly complex, they're like a machine - each part has its own function - but if each bit of the assembly line isn't overseen, tuned, coordinated, held to account in a specific manner that relates to the overall outcome, then what is produced is worthless.
I end up wondering; Why have Evatt, Bruce and Critchley part 2 (none of whom should have been overawed by managing us or found it a task beyond them) all ended up looking like husks of men? Why does it feel like virtually every player we sign seems to sink into a swamp of mediocrity?
The ultimate question has to be - What is wrong with the culture of the club and what else do we need to do to fix it, other than spinning the managerial merry-go-round and seeing who falls off it this time?
When we've done that, when we're clear about what we are, who we are, how we're going to get everyone involved to give everything to being the absolute best we can possibly be, then we can go and get a manager.
For the immediate, I honestly don't care. Blinks with Thommo for 3 months. Go and get Keogh for 6 months to play chaosball and at least it will be fun. I'd pay extra money on top of my season ticket just to see players look like they're actually enjoying it. Programme an AI with all the Billy Ayre quotes we can find and let that do the job. Whatever.
To throw another manager into this without some introspection and some proper reflection feels like repeatedly putting up a building on the same patch of sand and watching it fall down over and over. I'm a fan, Sadler's a fan. Weve both invested time and money into this, (granted, there's a question of scale) - I can't say anything else than what I'm saying - teams who have smaller budgets and better plans, clearer purpose, clearer identities, better defined standards, more consistent recruitment are out performing us by miles and it's pissing me off as it feels like a waste of time. I don't expect anything specific in terms of outcome - but I do expect us to compete to the best of our ability and we've gone backwards and looked further and further from doing that.
To imagine we're just 'unlucky' and that we just need 'the right manager' is not serving us well. We need to learn from our own history, from what is happening around us and have some conviction in what we're doing.
Some fun facts - Lincoln (championship team, 100 points last season, a budget 25% smaller than ours) not only got promoted with a first time manager, then installed another first timer when he left but have recruited 5 of the last 6 managers without any league experience. 4 of the current top 6 in League One have first time managers (or at least managers in their first permanent league jobs)
The point is - new is good, fresh is good, energy is good, youth is good. We act like we're scared of those things and it makes me wonder why? What are we lacking that prevents us from embracing risk? Why do we keep making (small c) conservative choices? What does it say about the tier above the manager if we can't let ourselves take risks?
We're fucking Blackpool, we're Tangerine. We are an absolute dream job for someone, we're a proper club, a proper fanbase, a fire that just needs rekindling and some oxygen. We shouldn't be looking at Stevenage and thinking "hmmm, what is their secret?" - We shouldn't be a club where it feels like everyone is walking through sinking sand with lead boots on - it's time, therefore, for a reckoning.
Evatt has gone and that's both a shame and the right thing at the same time. It was serving no one well - but just hoping someone else can turn up and sprinkle some magic dust on the thing is simplistic. Football has never been harder, it's never been more serious and more competitive and it takes more than just the right man in the dugout to make it work.
Mainly, though, let's go and batter Wigan.
Onward
You can follow MCLF on facebook, Twitter, Bluesky, Threads and Instagram or use Follow.it to get posts sent to your email If you appreciate the blog and judge it worth 1p or more, then a donation to one of the causes below which help kids and families in Blackpool would be grand.
Writing about football is possibly a bit pointless in an era when there's the telly and youtube and videos all over the shop. It's not my living this and it's just something I do because I do so there's no problem with reading it and then getting on with your life - but if you do want to chuck some money at the cause of some random fella writing shit no one ever asked him too, then Patreon. is a thing.








.jpeg)


















